How an E-Collar Ruined My Dog's Trust

From Best Friend to Fearful Foe: How an E-Collar Ruined My Dog’s Trust

As a dog owner, I always strive to provide the best care and training for my furry companion. So when I heard about e-collar training, I was intrigued. The idea of being able to control my dog's behavior with the push of a button seemed like a dream come true. Little did I know, this decision would ultimately ruin my dog's trust in me and our relationship.

In this article, I will share my personal experience with e-collar training and why I believe it should be avoided at all costs.

What is E-Collar Training?

E-collar training, also known as electronic collar training, is a method of dog training that uses a remote-controlled collar to deliver an electric shock to the dog's neck as a form of punishment. The shock is meant to deter unwanted behaviors such as barking, jumping, or running away.

Proponents of e-collar training claim that it is a quick and effective way to train dogs, as the shock is meant to be a mild and harmless correction. However, as I learned firsthand, this is not always the case.

My Experience with E-Collar Training

Dog with e-collar

by Jonathan Daniels (

I decided to try e-collar training with my dog, Max, after struggling with his excessive barking and jumping. I was assured by the trainer that the shock would be similar to a static shock and would not harm my dog. I was also told that the collar would only be used as a last resort and that positive reinforcement would still be the primary method of training.

At first, I saw some improvement in Max's behavior. He seemed to respond well to the collar and would stop barking or jumping when I pressed the button. However, as time went on, I noticed a change in his demeanor.

Max became more anxious and fearful, especially when I would reach for the remote. He would cower and hide, and it broke my heart to see him so scared. I also noticed that he was becoming more aggressive towards other dogs and people, which was completely out of character for him.

I decided to stop using the e-collar and sought out a different trainer who used positive reinforcement methods. It was then that I realized the true extent of the damage the e-collar had caused.

The Negative Effects of E-Collar Training

Physical Harm

While proponents of e-collar training claim that the shock is harmless, it can actually cause physical harm to dogs. The shock can cause burns, cuts, and even heart problems. In some cases, the shock can be strong enough to cause a dog to lose consciousness.

In addition, the constant pressure of the collar on the dog's neck can lead to neck injuries and discomfort. This can be especially harmful for breeds with short or sensitive necks.

Psychological Damage

Dog hiding

by Marcus Löfvenberg (

The psychological damage caused by e-collar training can be even more detrimental than the physical harm. Dogs are intelligent and sensitive creatures, and the shock from the collar can cause them to associate fear and pain with their owner.

This can lead to a breakdown of trust and a damaged relationship between the dog and their owner. In my case, Max went from being my best friend to a fearful and anxious dog who no longer trusted me.

Inconsistent Training

E-collar training relies on punishment rather than positive reinforcement, which can lead to inconsistent training. Dogs may not understand why they are being shocked and may become confused and anxious. This can result in unpredictable behavior and a lack of trust in their owner.

In addition, the shock may not always be effective in deterring unwanted behaviors. Dogs may become desensitized to the shock or may not associate the shock with their behavior, leading to continued unwanted behaviors.

Positive Alternatives to E-Collar Training

There are many positive and effective alternatives to e-collar training that can help train your dog without causing harm or damaging your relationship.

Positive Reinforcement Training

Positive reinforcement training focuses on rewarding desired behaviors rather than punishing unwanted behaviors. This can include treats, praise, and playtime as rewards for good behavior.

This method of training is not only more humane, but it also strengthens the bond between the dog and their owner. Dogs learn to trust and respect their owner rather than fear them.

Clicker Training

Dog with clicker

by Dominik QN (

Clicker training is a form of positive reinforcement training that uses a clicker to mark desired behaviors. The clicker is paired with a reward, such as a treat, to reinforce the behavior.

This method is highly effective and can be used for a variety of behaviors, from basic obedience to more complex tricks. It also allows for clear communication between the dog and their owner, leading to a stronger bond and better understanding.

Professional Training

If you are struggling with training your dog, seeking out a professional trainer who uses positive reinforcement methods is always a better option than e-collar training. They can provide personalized training for your dog and help you build a strong and trusting relationship.


E-collar training may seem like a quick and easy solution for training your dog, but the negative effects far outweigh any potential benefits. Not only can it cause physical harm, but it can also lead to psychological damage and a breakdown of trust between you and your dog.

Instead, opt for positive reinforcement training methods that focus on building a strong and positive relationship with your dog. Your furry friend will thank you for it.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *