best shock collar for dogs

10 Safest Shock Collars For Dogs – The Simple, Easy Guide For Best Dog Training Collar

If you are considering purchasing a shock collar for your dog, make sure to read the instructions and follow all safety precautions.

Shock collars are a popular type of dog behavior modification device but are there really any safest shock collars for dogs? Being a proud dog owner I have always been curious about the efficacy and safety of these training devices. Like me, I am sure most dog owners have the same question in mind.

But what if I tell you that you can find the safest shock collars for your dogs?

The goal of these collars is to train your dog or modify its stubborn behavior when all other training methods have failed. The shock collar is simply programmed to deliver a mild electric shock to the dog’s neck, which is a stimulation designed to train the dog.

This can be a great tool for the first-time dog owner who wants to teach a dog but doesn’t want to punish the dog because that can potentially have a negative effect on his behavior.

We have tested many types of collars available in the market and in our opinion, these are the 10 best dog training collars.

As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases

What Should Be the Safety Features of Safest Shock Collars

Safety FeatureDescription
Adjustable Stimulation LevelsAllows pet owners to choose the appropriate level of static stimulation based on the dog's sensitivity and training needs.
Warning SignalsProvides warning signals, such as vibrations or tones, to alert the dog before delivering a static stimulation. This helps the dog associate the warning with the correction, promoting clear communication.
Auto Shut-offAutomatically turns off the static stimulation after a certain period of time to prevent prolonged exposure and potential discomfort to the dog.
Waterproof DesignMade with waterproof materials to ensure the collar remains functional and safe in wet conditions or when the dog is exposed to water.
Impact ResistanceConstructed with durable materials to withstand impact and rough handling, reducing the risk of damage to the collar during active play or outdoor activities.
Comfortable FitDesigned to provide a comfortable and secure fit on the dog's neck, minimizing the risk of irritation or discomfort associated with wearing the collar.
Safety LockEquipped with a safety lock mechanism to prevent accidental activation or unintentional changes in stimulation levels.
Battery IndicatorIncludes a battery indicator to alert the user when the collar's battery needs to be recharged or replaced, ensuring consistent functionality.
User Manual and SupportProvides a comprehensive user manual with clear instructions on proper usage and safety guidelines. The manufacturer offers customer support to address any questions or concerns regarding the collar's safety.

10 Safest Shock Collars For Dogs

Dogtra 200C

Dogtra 200C

  • One-handed operation
  • Waterproof
  • ½-Mile Range
  • Ultra-compact design
Educator E-Collar

Educator E-Collar

  • 1/2 Mile Range
  • Biothane collar strap
  • Small receiver
  • Stimulation levels from 1 to 100
Garmin Delta Sport XC

Garmin Delta Sport XC

  • 3/4 Mile Range
  • 5 Correction/training configurations
  • Built-in bark limiter
  • Battery life-80 hours per charge
Dogtra iQ Mini

Dogtra iQ Mini

  • Range 400 yards
  • 100 correction levels
  • Expandable to two dogs
  • Waterproof
Dogtra iQ Plus

Dogtra iQ Plus

  • Range 400 yards
  • 100 correction levels
  • Expandable to two dogs
  • Waterproof
SportDOG Brand 425X

SportDOG Brand 425X

  • 500 Yard Range
  • Tone, vibration, or 21 levels of static stimulation
  • Waterproof
  • Rechargeable


  • Up to ¾ Mile Range
  • Static, Vibration, and Tone
  • Waterproof
  • Rechargeable


  • 3 Training Modes
  • Waterproof
  • Adjustable Belt
Educator E-Collar

Educator E-Collar

  • 1/2 Mile Range
  • Biothane collar
  • Stimulation levels from 1 to 100
Sport Trainer Remote Sport Dog

Sport Trainer Remote Sport Dog

  • ¾ Mile Range
  • Easy-to-read OLED screen
  • Submersible to 25 feet
  • Fits dogs 8 pounds or larger
Safest Shock Collars For Dogs

Dogtra 200C- Best overall

Dogtra 200C- Best overall

The Dogtra 200C is a safe shock collar for dogs that offers 100 correction levels and positive reinforcement training. It also features a one-handed operation via the Rheostat Dial, as well as a “No look” control design to make it easier to use. The HPP (High-Performance Pager) feature emits an audible tone before the stimulation to warn your dog and prevent any accidental corrections.

The Dogtra 200C is a compact and lightweight training collar that is completely waterproof for shock training. With an IPX8 rating, it can be submerged in up to 1 meter of water for 30 minutes, making it ideal for use in any weather conditions. Additionally, the collar features an IPX9K rating, which means it is protected against high-pressure water jets. This makes the Dogtra 200C perfect for hunting or working dogs that need to be trained in wet environments.

The Dogtra 200C is one of the most popular shock collars on the market, and it's easy to see why. It features a LED indicator light that shows you when the collar is turned on, making it easy to avoid over-corrections. Additionally, this unit is perfect for basic obedience and entry-level fieldwork.

Dogtra 200C Remote Training Collar – 1/2 Mile Range, Rechargeable, Waterproof – Plus 1 iClick Training Card, Jestik Click Trainer – Value Bundle
  • Dogtra 200C e-collar is a compact intuitive remote training tool for even the mildest mannered dogs of 10 pounds and up.
  • Dogtra 200C e-collar features a 1/2-mile range and is fully waterproof.
  • The new ergo dynamic handheld transmitter is designed with the user in mind by optimally placing buttons for one-handed operation.
  • Nick, Constant Stimulation, and Non-Stimulating High Performance Pager Vibration modes. Rheostat/Volume Dial with low-high stimulation from 0-100 levels
  • Value Bundle Includes 1 iClick Training card, Jestik Click Trainer

Last update on 2024-05-19 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Educator E-Collar – Best For Shock Training

safest shock collar for dogs

The Educator E-Collar is a safe and humane way to train your dog. It is one dog system with a 1/2 mile range. The points for hair and comfort pads come separately, so you can customize the collar on your dog.

The e-collar uses 1 to 100 shock levels, intended to help train dogs and stop unwanted behaviors. The e-collar is meant to be used by professionals and their dogs.

It features a receiver and transmitter made with hypoallergenic titanium points that won't irritate your pet's skin. Additionally, the collar has a vibration mode for added reinforcement.

Garmin Delta Sport XC- Best Dog Training Collar

Garmin Delta Sport XC

The Garmin Delta Sport XC is a high-quality, safe shock training collar. It features long and short contact points, 36 levels of stimulation, and a range of up to 3/4 mile. The handheld has an 80-hour battery life, making it perfect for extended training sessions or fieldwork.

Delta Sport XC is a dog device that offers 5 correction/training configurations for tackling different behavioral issues. The device also has a battery life of 80 hours per charge and is compatible with 3 other dogs. 

The Garmin Delta Sport XC is an excellent option for those looking for a reliable and safe shock collar. The collar features an auto bark correction mode, as well as the BarkLimiter, which can be adjusted from the handheld and in my opinion one of the best collars for stubborn dogs.

Dogtra iQ Mini- Best Bark Collar

Dogtra iQ Mini

The Dogtra iQ Mini is a small, lightweight collar that is perfect for dogs under 25 pounds. It has 100 levels of correction and a rheostat dial adjustment, which means you can fine-tune the correction to your dog's exact needs. This makes it an ideal choice for correcting minor behavioral issues.

The Dogtra iQ Mini is a great choice for dog owners who want to train their dogs with collar training. It's expandable to two dogs and is compatible with the Dogtra iQ Plus. You can also control your dog up to 400 yards away. The simple commands make it easy to use, even if you're not familiar with using shock collars.

Dogtra iQ Plus-Best For Stubborn Dogs

safest shock collar for small dogs

The Dogtra iQ Plus is a compact, small dog-specific electronic training collar. It has 100 levels of correction and one-handed operation for easy use. The adjustable correction levels make it perfect for any dog's size and temperament.

The Dogtra iQ Plus dog collar is the perfect choice for those who are looking for an expandable transmitter with a durable product. The product is made with class-leading customer service tools and a team. Furthermore, the products are meant to ensure the best customer experience, making them one of the safest shock collars on the market.

SportDOG Brand 425X – Best For Positive Reinforcement Training

SportDOG Brand 425X

The SportDOG Brand 425X is a long-range e-collar that can be used to train up to three dogs with one remote. It has a maximum range of 500 yards.

The SportDOG Brand 425X is a vibration-only, static-simulated, and tone-only collar that offers 21 levels of stimulation. This collar also has a rechargeable battery and an LCD screen.

The SportDOG Brand 425X is a durable, waterproof, and submersible collar that can be used for dogs up to 25 pounds. Read our complete review



SPORT TRAINER is a remote training collar designed for field training and hunting with close-working dogs. It is also suitable for obedience training of larger dogs (8 pounds or more) that have a neck size of at least 5 inches. The collar offers 10 levels of stimulation, each adjustable from 0 to 100 intensity levels, making it perfect for any dog temperament.

The Sport Trainer is a great choice for those who are looking for a submersible e-collar. The unit features a 25-foot deep waterproof rating, as well as a lithium-ion battery that only takes 2 hours to charge fully. Additionally, there is a low battery indicator to let you know when it's time to recharge and an included remote transmitter with a removable antenna.


bark collar

The PATPET training collar is a safe and humane way to train your professional dog. It has three training modes: beep, vibration, and static levels. This allows you to find the mode that works best for many dogs. Additionally, the collar has a safety stop function that will automatically turn off the shock after 15 seconds.

The wireless remote provides long-range control with the receiver. The receiver is IPX7 waterproof and the remote is IPX5 rainproof. This ensures that you'll be able to train your dog even in inclement weather conditions.

The PATPET Shock Collar has a number of features to make dog training easier and is used by professional dog trainers. For one, the rechargeable lithium-ion battery ensures that you can keep on training your dog without any interruptions. Additionally, the distinguishing button helps you keep track of which remote is which, making it easier to give commands.

Educator E-Collar Dog Training

Educator E-Collar Dog Training

The Educator E-Collar is safe and easy to use for shock collar training. It features a 1/2 mile range and the receiver size is 2″ x 1.5″. The transmitter size is 2.4 oz, making it easy to carry with you.

The Educator E-Collar Dog Training system is a great choice for those who are looking for features such as the Pavlovian tone feature, hypoallergenic titanium points, and comfort pads that can be used more than 8 hours a day.

There are a number of different factors to consider when shopping for the best shock collar for your dog. One important consideration is the amount of time the collar can be worn comfortably. Shock collars with comfort pads can be worn for up to eight hours per day, while those without comfort pads may only be able to be worn for a few hours at a time. Another important consideration is the material used in the construction of the points. Titanium is hypoallergenic and will not cause an allergic reaction in dogs with nickel allergies.

Sport Trainer Remote

Sport Trainer Remote

The Sport Trainer Remote is designed for field training and hunting dogs. The OLED screen displays the selected dog, static stimulation level, and battery status so you can view it with just a glance.

The Sport Trainer Remote Dog Training Collar also offers 10 levels of both continuous and momentary static stimulation, as well as vibration (buzz) and tone options. The vibration is a good way to get your dog's attention when you need it without having to resort to an electric shock.

Top-of-the-line Sport Trainer Remote Dog Shock Collars come with a host of features that pet owners will love. For instance, the battery life is five hours and the collar is waterproof up to 25 feet. In addition, the collars recharge quickly with a lithium-ion battery and have low battery indicators to let you know when it's time for a recharge.

What is a shock collar?

Shock collars are simple devices that deliver a mild electric shock to the dog’s neck. They can be used for training, correction, or modifying stubborn behavior. The shock collar is simple to use. It is one of the most popular training tools on the market.  They don’t cause any significant physical harm to the dog and they don’t do any damage to the dog.

How does a shock collar work?

A shock collar is a tool used to administer an electric shock in order to train or punish an animal. The dog will typically feel the pain of the electric shock and try to avoid it by following the instructions given by their owner.

The dog's throat contains many pressure points, and when the dog barks or growls, the vibration from its vocal cords is translated into electric impulses. The dog shock collar is able to pick up these electric impulses and deliver the correct amount of shock to your dog, depending on the intensity setting you have it on.

What are the benefits of a shock collar?

Shock collars remain a controversial training tool but are still often utilized due to their benefits, which include, but are not limited to, improved obedience, reduced aggression, and quicker learning times. The benefits of a shock collar are undeniable, but it's important to know what type of shock collar is safe for your dog.

Some people argue that shock collars are an effective way to train dogs. The proponents of this tool claim that shock collars can be used to quickly and easily train dogs to obey commands and stop bad behavior. They assert that using a shock collar can save time and effort in training dogs, as it reduces the need for repetitive, time-consuming training sessions. Some shock collar manufacturers also state that the device has several advantages, including versatility, affordability, and compatibility with different dog sizes and breeds.

What are the risks of shock collars?

The shocks are often painful and can cause lasting physical and psychological damage if used incorrectly. They remain a controversial training tool but are often effective for training stubborn dogs.

Shock collars are often banned in some countries because of the potential risks they pose to dogs. These risks can include physical and psychological injuries, pain, and even death. However, shock collars are still used in America and other countries.

How to use a shock collar safely?

All the safest shock collars for dogs have different intensity levels. This enables you to choose the static stimulation level that is most appropriate for your dog. For the safety of your dog, it is essential to know the proper intensity level for your dog. This is known as the Recognition Level, at which your dog appears to be curious and looks all around or moves his ears. 

To find out the exact level, you should start at the lowest level and gradually increase the intensity. Every dog is unique, and it is impossible to predict what your dog’s Recognition Level is going to be. You must observe carefully for any minor change in conduct that will show you the reaction of your dog to stimulation. Your dog should not express or show anxiety or pain through strange actions or barking loudly when receiving stimulation.

If your dog is uneasy, then the stimulation level is obviously high, and you need to comfort your dog by going to the previous level. After establishing the Recognition Level of your dog, now you can safely use your shock collar and start training your dog. 

How to pick the right shock collar for your dog? 

A good shock collar is more effective than a bad shock collar, but the bad shock collar may not only be less effective but even more dangerous than a good one. There are a lot of shock collars on the market, so it can be difficult to tell which ones are best suited to your dog. The thumb rule is that it should be comfortable for dogs and easy for you to use.

Once you decide to purchase a shock collar, it is important that you make sure that the collar actually fits your dog. You must consider the size of your dog, and check for the type of hair on your dog as it will lead you to decide about the type of contact points on the shock collar. The wireless range of the remote control, its battery time, whether the collar is waterproof or not, and the price which you are willing to spend. Before you purchase a shock collar, must consider the following points:-

Signaling Modes

There are a few different signaling modes that are available on most dog shock collars. The most common are static shocks, vibrations, and tones. It is always recommended to start with the lowest setting possible and increase the correction level only if necessary. Additionally, it is important to be aware of how your dog reacts to corrections before increasing the intensity.

Effective ranges

There are a variety of shock collars on the market, with different ranges. The most common range for a shock collar is 800 to 1,000 feet. So once you are ready to purchase a shock collar for your dog, first decide, where and how you are going to use it.

It is always recommended to purchase a shock collar that comes with a remote control because it provides you the ability to correct your dog from a distance.

Levels of shock

There are different levels of shock that a dog shock collar can deliver, and the intensity of each level varies depending on the settings. Level 1 is the least intense, while the highest level is the most intense.


Almost all popular shock collar brands are water-resistant. But some are waterproof also as being waterproof requires that the shock collar should be able to work once submerged under water.


The cost of a dog shock collar depends on the model and range. Typically, they start at around $60 and can go up to $200 or more. That said, it's always important to do your research.

Safest Shock Collar | FAQs

Why shouldn't you use a choke collar?

Choke collars are ineffective tools and can cause harm. Dogs have been shown to be more likely to respond to positive reinforcement than punishment-based training methods, which is why using a choke collar is not only ineffective but can also be harmful to the dog.

Are shock collars bad for dogs?

No, shock collars are not bad for dogs. Shock collars are often used during training sessions to reinforce behavior or teach a dog new commands. The only time that shock collars should not be used is when the dog is in distress, as this can cause additional stress.

Are vibration collars good for dogs?

Vibration collars are a good way to keep your dog on task and limit his or her behavior. They emit an unpleasant vibration that gives the animal a mild shock when he or she misbehaves. However, if your dog is not trained well enough or doesn't respond to the vibration, it might cause more harm than good.

Are static collars the same as shock collars?

Static collars are not the same as shock collars. Static collars are primarily used for training purposes and do not use an electric current to provide stimulation. Shock collars have a metal prong that is activated with an electric current, and the stimulation can come in different forms, including a static shock.

Is a prong collar cruel?

This is a difficult question to answer because it depends on what you mean by “cruel.” If you are asking whether the prong collar causes more harm than good, then the answer is no. If you are asking whether the prong collar is more humane than a metal choke collar, then the answer is also no.

What shock collars do police dogs use?

Shock collars are used on police dogs in order to train them or punish them. They come in many forms, with the most common being a remote-controlled collar that emits an electric shock to the dog when it does something wrong, such as jumping on someone or biting.

Is a vibration collar the same as a shock collar?

Vibration collars are electronic devices that deliver a mild sensation to a dog's neck or back when they display undesirable behaviors. A shock collar, on the other hand, delivers an electric shock to a dog's neck or back when it displays undesirable behaviors.

Do dog trainers recommend shock collars?

The shock collars are meant for use in the training and rehabilitation of dogs. Trainers recommend the use of the collars for the following reasons:

– to stop dogs from barking or growling

– to help with behavioral problems such as separation anxiety and aggression

– to improve recall, especially when a dog is off-leash

– to help with housebreaking.

Is a stimulation collar a shock collar?

A stimulation collar is a training tool that delivers a mild electric shock when the dog's behavior becomes problematic. It uses an electrical current to condition the dog to stop its aggressive or disruptive behavior.

How to treat shock collar soars?

If your dog ever needs a good shock collar sore treatment, you’re going to want to see this one.

Shock Collar Sore Treatment: 9 Effective Home Remedies With No Painkillers Or Medication Needed


Above list of safest shock collar for dogs is, what we have tested and found best for dogs. In no way it is the ultimate or final list. Before purchasing any collar for your dog, you are advised to do market research and do let us know, if you find any other safe collar.

You may like to read more about shock collars:-

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *